Theories and Models

Community Dentistry15 min read
On this page 31 sections

💡Major health behaviour models

Theory/modelMain conceptFCPS recognition clue
Health Belief Model (HBM)Behaviour depends on perceived susceptibility, severity, benefits, barriers, cues to action and self-efficacyPatient acts because they believe they are at risk and treatment will help
Theory of Planned Behaviour (TPB)Behaviour is predicted by intention, which depends on attitude, subjective norms and perceived behavioural controlSocial pressure and perceived control influence intention
Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA)Intention is influenced by attitude and subjective normsBehaviour is largely intentional and under voluntary control
Social Cognitive Theory (SCT)Behaviour, personal factors and environment influence each otherObservational learning, role models, self-efficacy and reinforcement
Transtheoretical Model (Stages of Change)Behaviour change occurs through stagesPatient is not ready, considering change, preparing, acting or maintaining
Protection Motivation Theory (PMT)Threat appraisal and coping appraisal influence protective behaviourPerceived threat plus belief that a response will work
Health Action Process Approach (HAPA)Separates motivation from translating intention into actionPatient intends to change but needs planning and coping strategies
Diffusion of InnovationsExplains how new ideas and practices spread through a populationInnovators, early adopters, early majority, late majority and laggards
PRECEDE–PROCEED ModelFramework for assessing needs, planning, implementing and evaluating health programmesPredisposing, reinforcing and enabling factors; programme evaluation
COM-B ModelBehaviour requires capability, opportunity and motivationIdentify which of the three components is preventing the desired behaviour

💡Health Belief Model

HBM is one of the most commonly tested models.

ComponentMeaningDental example
Perceived susceptibilityBelief about personal risk“My frequent sugar intake puts me at risk of caries.”
Perceived severityBelief about seriousness“Untreated caries could cause pain and tooth loss.”
Perceived benefitsBelief that action will help“Fluoride toothpaste will reduce my risk.”
Perceived barriersObstacles to taking action“I cannot afford regular dental visits.”
Cues to actionTrigger that initiates behaviourA dentist's advice, reminder or educational message
Self-efficacyConfidence in one's ability to act“I can brush twice daily and reduce sugary snacks.”

MCQ trap: A patient knows oral cancer is serious but does not attend screening because they believe they are unlikely to develop it. The key HBM construct is low perceived susceptibility.

Theory of Planned Behaviour vs Theory of Reasoned Action

FeatureTRATPB
AttitudeIncludedIncluded
Subjective normsIncludedIncluded
Perceived behavioural controlNot a core componentIncluded
Best applicationVoluntary behavioursBehaviours where control or resources may be limited

Exam pearl: “I intend to quit smoking, but I don't think I can manage withdrawal or avoid triggers” points towards perceived behavioural control in TPB.

💡Transtheoretical Model — stages of change

Figure: 💡Transtheoretical Model — stages of change
  • Relapse can occur; change is not always linear.
  • Dental example: A smoker who is not considering quitting is in precontemplation; someone who has selected a quit date and is arranging support is in preparation.

Other behavioural theories that are easy to miss

These are worth adding to your revision list because they explain why patients adopt, maintain or fail to adopt health behaviours. Behavioural theories are also used in oral-health research and periodontal health interventions.

TheoryMain conceptExample / MCQ clue
Social Learning Theory — BanduraPeople learn by observing and imitating othersA child copies a parent's toothbrushing
Self-efficacy theory — BanduraConfidence in one's ability to perform an actionA patient believes they can quit smoking
Locus of Control — RotterWhether outcomes are attributed to internal or external control“My oral health depends on my actions” vs “It is all fate”
Self-Determination TheoryIntrinsic vs extrinsic motivation; autonomy, competence and relatednessPatient brushes because they personally value oral health, not just to avoid punishment
Self-Regulation TheoryPeople monitor and adjust behaviour using goals and feedbackTracking plaque scores or brushing performance
Cognitive Dissonance Theory — FestingerConflict between beliefs and behaviour creates psychological discomfortA smoker who knows smoking is harmful but continues may rationalize the behaviour
Attribution TheoryHow people explain the causes of events influences future behaviourA patient attributes caries to bad luck rather than frequent sugar intake
Health Locus of ControlHealth control may be internal, attributed to powerful others, or chance“Only my dentist can keep my teeth healthy”
Salutogenesis — AntonovskyFocuses on factors that support health rather than only causes of diseaseResources, coping and sense of coherence help maintain wellbeing
Protection Motivation TheoryThreat appraisal + coping appraisal influence protective actionA patient uses protective measures because the threat is serious and the action seems effective
Precaution Adoption Process ModelDistinguishes being unaware, unengaged, deciding and actingA person has never considered oral cancer screening, then gradually decides to attend
Self-Regulatory Model / Common-Sense Model of IllnessIllness beliefs influence coping and treatment behaviourA patient believes bleeding gums are normal and therefore does not seek care

💡The three concepts frequently confused in MCQs

ConceptWhat it asks
Locus of controlWho or what controls the health outcome?
Self-efficacyAm I capable of performing the behaviour?
Perceived behavioural controlHow much control do I believe I have over performing the behaviour, including barriers?

They overlap, but they are not interchangeable.

💡Health education and learning theories

These overlap heavily with Community Medicine, health promotion, health education and preventive dentistry.

Theory / principleMain conceptTypical exam clue
Classical conditioning — PavlovAssociation between two stimuli produces a learned responseA previously neutral stimulus triggers a response after repeated pairing
Operant conditioning — SkinnerBehaviour is shaped by consequencesRewards, reinforcement and punishment
Observational learning — BanduraLearning by watching a modelChildren imitate parents or teachers
Cognitive learning theoryLearning involves mental processes, understanding and organization of informationPatient understands why fluoride prevents caries
ConstructivismLearners build new understanding from previous experienceInteractive, problem-based patient education
Experiential learning — KolbLearning through experience, reflection, conceptualization and experimentationDemonstration followed by practice and feedback
Adult learning theory — Knowles (andragogy)Adults learn best when relevant, practical and connected to their experienceA patient learns a skill that solves an immediate problem
Social learning / social cognitive theoryLearning through observation, modelling, reinforcement and self-efficacyDemonstrating brushing to a group of children
Theory of Multiple Intelligences — GardnerPeople may have different strengths in processing informationUsing visual, verbal and hands-on teaching methods
Bloom's TaxonomyClassifies cognitive learning objectives from simpler to more complexRecall, understanding, application, analysis, evaluation and creation

Classical vs operant conditioning

FeatureClassical conditioningOperant conditioning
Associated withIvan PavlovB. F. Skinner
Learning mechanismAssociation between stimuliConsequences of behaviour
Main focusStimulus-response associationBehaviour followed by reinforcement or punishment
ExampleA patient associates a dental clinic's sounds with anxiety after a painful experienceA child receives praise for brushing correctly and repeats the behaviour

💡Reinforcement vs punishment

TermMeaningExample
Positive reinforcementAdd something desirable to increase behaviourPraise a child for brushing
Negative reinforcementRemove something unpleasant to increase behaviourA reminder stops once the agreed behaviour is completed
Positive punishmentAdd an unpleasant consequence to reduce behaviourAdding an aversive consequence after an unwanted behaviour
Negative punishmentRemove something desirable to reduce behaviourRemoving a privilege after an unwanted behaviour

Important: In psychology, negative means removal, not necessarily something harmful. Reinforcement increases behaviour; punishment decreases it.

Bloom's Taxonomy — cognitive domain

LevelWhat the learner doesDental example
RememberRecalls factsNames the causes of caries
UnderstandExplains meaningExplains the role of plaque
ApplyUses knowledgeDemonstrates the correct brushing technique
AnalyzeBreaks information into partsIdentifies why a patient has recurrent caries
EvaluateMakes a justified judgmentCompares two preventive strategies
CreateProduces something newDesigns an oral-health education programme

The classic version is often taught as knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation. The revised version uses remember, understand, apply, analyze, evaluate and create.

💡Health promotion models and planning frameworks

These are particularly relevant to community-based prevention programmes, school dental health projects, tobacco cessation and population-level interventions.

💡A. PRECEDE–PROCEED Model

A major framework for planning and evaluating health-promotion programmes.

PRECEDE focuses on assessment and planning; PROCEED focuses on implementation and evaluation.

PRECEDE components

FactorMeaningDental example
PredisposingKnowledge, attitudes, beliefs and motivationParents do not know that frequent sugar intake causes caries
ReinforcingFeedback and social consequences that support behaviourFamily and teachers encourage toothbrushing
EnablingResources, skills and access that make behaviour possibleAvailability of toothbrushes, fluoride toothpaste and affordable dental services

The classic PRECEDE framework includes social assessment, epidemiological assessment, behavioural and environmental assessment, educational/ecological assessment, and administrative/policy assessment.

PROCEED and evaluation

Evaluation typeWhat is assessed?Example
Process evaluationWas the programme implemented as planned?Number of schools visited
Impact evaluationDid knowledge, behaviour or immediate risk factors change?Improvement in brushing technique
Outcome evaluationDid longer-term health outcomes improve?Reduced caries prevalence

Exam clue: Predisposing, reinforcing and enabling factors point to PRECEDE. Process, impact and outcome evaluation are commonly tested alongside the PRECEDE–PROCEED framework.

Figure: PROCEED and evaluation

💡Ottawa Charter for Health Promotion

The Ottawa Charter (1986) is a core health-promotion framework in Community Medicine.

Action areaMeaningDental example
Build healthy public policyPolicies that support healthRestrictions on tobacco advertising
Create supportive environmentsMake healthy choices easierSugar-free choices available in schools
Strengthen community actionCommunities participate in decisionsCommunity-led oral-health campaigns
Develop personal skillsImprove health knowledge and practical skillsBrushing and oral cancer awareness education
Reorient health servicesShift from treatment alone towards preventionPreventive dental services and risk-based recall

Three basic strategies: Advocate, enable and mediate.

💡Social Ecological Model

Health behaviour is shaped by multiple interacting levels, not just individual choice.

LevelExample
IndividualKnowledge, beliefs, skills
InterpersonalFamily, friends and peers
OrganizationalSchool or workplace policies
CommunityLocal norms and access to dental clinics
Policy / societalTobacco taxation, fluoride policy and regulations

MCQ clue: A question asking you to address an oral-health problem through individual counselling, family support, school policies and legislation is pointing towards the Social Ecological Model.

💡Community Medicine models, theories and frameworks

These are not exclusively dental. They appear in public health, health services, epidemiology, community diagnosis and health planning.

💡Models of disease causation

ModelMain conceptExample / recognition clue
Epidemiological triadDisease results from interaction between agent, host and environmentCaries: cariogenic biofilm, susceptible tooth/host and dietary/environmental factors
Web of causationMultiple interrelated factors contribute to diseasePeriodontitis involving smoking, diabetes, plaque, genetics and social factors
Wheel of causationHost factors interact with a biological, physical and social environment; no single agent is necessarily centralMultifactorial chronic disease
Sufficient-component cause model (Rothman)A disease occurs when a complete causal mechanism, or sufficient cause, is assembled from component causesSeveral combinations of risk factors can lead to the same disease
Natural history of diseaseDisease progresses through stages without interventionPreclinical disease followed by clinical disease and possible outcomes
Iceberg phenomenonDiagnosed clinical cases represent only part of the total burdenMany cases of early caries or hypertension remain undetected
Spectrum of diseaseDisease ranges from subclinical infection to severe illnessInfection with varying degrees of symptoms
Multifactorial causationMultiple risk factors jointly influence diseaseCaries and periodontal disease

Epidemiological triad vs web of causation

FeatureEpidemiological triadWeb of causation
StructureAgent–host–environmentInterconnected causal factors
Best suited toMany infectious disease examples; also useful for broader disease analysisComplex chronic diseases
Main ideaInteraction among three broad componentsMultiple linked pathways can produce disease

Rothman's sufficient-component cause model

  • A sufficient cause is a complete causal mechanism that produces the outcome.
  • A component cause is one part of that mechanism.
  • A necessary cause is present in every sufficient causal mechanism for a particular outcome.
  • A component cause need not be necessary on its own.

Exam clue: A disease occurs only when a particular combination of factors is complete, but different combinations can produce the same disease.

💡Natural history of disease and levels of prevention

StageDescriptionPrevention
PrimordialPrevent emergence of risk factorsHealthy public policy, healthy school environments
PrimaryPrevent disease before it occursFluoride exposure, tobacco avoidance, immunization
SecondaryDetect disease early and treat promptlyScreening and early treatment of oral potentially malignant disorders
TertiaryReduce disability and restore function after established diseaseRehabilitation after oral cancer surgery
QuaternaryAvoid unnecessary or harmful medical interventionAvoid unnecessary investigations and overtreatment

Important distinction: Primordial prevention prevents the development of risk factors; primary prevention prevents disease in an individual who may already have risk factors.

Epidemiological transition theory

Associated with Abdel Omran.

  • Describes changes in the leading causes of illness and death as populations and societies develop.
  • Broadly, infectious diseases and high mortality become less dominant, while chronic noncommunicable diseases account for a larger proportion of disease burden.
  • Modern populations may experience a double burden of communicable and noncommunicable diseases.

Dental application: A population may continue to experience infectious diseases and untreated oral disease while also seeing increasing diabetes, oral cancer and other chronic conditions.

Demographic transition model

Describes changes in birth and death rates as a population transitions through stages of development.

StageBirth rateDeath ratePopulation pattern
I — High stationaryHighHighSlow growth
II — Early expandingHighFallingRapid growth
III — Late expandingFallingLowGrowth slows
IV — Low stationaryLowLowStable or slow growth
V — Declining (in some models)Very lowLow or rising relative to birthsNatural decrease

MCQ clue: Death rates fall before birth rates, producing rapid population growth in stage II.

Diffusion of Innovations — Everett Rogers

Explains how a new idea, technology or health practice spreads through a social system.

Adopter groupApproximate proportionCharacteristics
Innovators2.5%First to adopt; willing to take risks
Early adopters13.5%Respected opinion leaders
Early majority34%Adopt before the average person
Late majority34%Adopt after much of the community
Laggards16%Last to adopt; often cautious about change

Dental example: Introducing a new preventive protocol, fluoride programme or digital dental service.

Exam clue: The question asks who adopts an innovation first or how an innovation spreads across a community.

💡Health services and access models

Model / conceptMain ideaExample
Andersen Behavioral Model of Health Services UseHealthcare use is influenced by predisposing, enabling and need factorsDental attendance depends on age/beliefs, affordability/access and perceived or assessed need
Inverse Care Law — Julian Tudor HartAvailability of good medical care tends to vary inversely with the need of the population servedUnderserved communities may have fewer dental services despite greater disease burden
Levesque framework of accessAccess depends on service accessibility and people's abilities to perceive, seek, reach, pay for and engage with careA clinic exists but patients cannot afford transport or treatment
Donabedian modelHealthcare quality is assessed through structure, process and outcomeDental clinic facilities, care delivered and resulting oral-health outcomes
Primary Health Care — Alma-AtaEssential, accessible healthcare with community participation and intersectoral actionCommunity-based oral-health promotion and basic preventive services

Donabedian model — very testable

ComponentMeaningDental example
StructureResources and settingTrained dental staff, equipment, sterilization facilities
ProcessWhat is done during careProper examination, prevention, treatment and counselling
OutcomeResult of careReduced caries, improved function and patient satisfaction

Memory aid: Structure = what you have; process = what you do; outcome = what happens.

💡Community diagnosis, health education and programme evaluation

Concept / frameworkMain ideaExam clue
KAP modelKnowledge, attitudes and practices are assessed to understand health behaviourA questionnaire measures what people know, believe and do
Community diagnosisSystematic assessment of a population's health problems, determinants and resourcesIdentifying the main oral-health needs of a district
Needs assessmentIdentifies gaps between current and desired health status or servicesDetermining unmet dental treatment needs
SMART objectivesSpecific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound objectives“Increase twice-daily brushing among schoolchildren by 20% within one year”
Logic modelLinks inputs, activities, outputs and outcomesStaff and supplies → school visits → children reached → improved brushing
RE-AIM frameworkEvaluates Reach, Effectiveness, Adoption, Implementation and MaintenanceAssessing whether a community intervention works and can be sustained
PRECEDE–PROCEEDLinks community assessment, intervention planning, implementation and evaluationPlanning a school oral-health programme

💡KAP vs HBM

FeatureKAPHBM
PurposeDescribes knowledge, attitudes and practicesExplains beliefs influencing health behaviour
Typical useCommunity surveysDesigning behavioural interventions
ExampleMeasuring the proportion who know fluoride prevents cariesInvestigating why someone avoids fluoride despite knowing its benefits

Important: Knowledge alone does not guarantee behaviour change. Attitudes, social influences, access, motivation and self-efficacy can also matter.

💡Theories of communication and interpersonal behaviour

These are useful for questions about counselling, patient compliance, health education and behaviour change.

Theory / conceptMain ideaExample
Shannon–Weaver communication modelSender, message, channel, receiver and noiseBackground noise prevents a patient from hearing instructions
Transactional model of communicationCommunication is a two-way, ongoing process with feedbackDentist and patient clarify each other's understanding
Osgood–Schramm modelCommunication involves reciprocal encoding, decoding and interpretationDentist and patient repeatedly exchange information
Maslow's hierarchy of needsPhysiological needs, safety, belonging, esteem and self-actualizationA patient struggling with basic needs may prioritize food and shelter over preventive dental visits
Theory of Social CapitalSocial networks, trust and reciprocity influence collective actionA trusted community leader encourages families to attend screening
Empowerment theoryPeople gain knowledge, control and capacity to influence decisions affecting their healthCommunities participate in designing oral-health programmes
Motivational interviewingCollaborative counselling helps resolve ambivalence and strengthen the patient's own motivationA smoker explores reasons for quitting without being lectured

💡Social theories and models of health

Theory / modelMain conceptRecognition clue
Social determinants of healthHealth is shaped by living conditions, income, education, work and access to servicesPoverty and housing influence health outcomes
Fundamental Cause TheorySocioeconomic resources influence multiple disease outcomes through flexible access to protective resourcesHigher socioeconomic groups can use new preventive information and treatments more readily
Inverse Care LawGood care may be least available where need is greatestAreas with high dental disease have insufficient services
Biomedical modelDisease is primarily explained through biological or physiological abnormalitiesFocus on diagnosing and treating pathology
Biopsychosocial model — EngelHealth and illness reflect biological, psychological and social interactionsChronic pain influenced by pathology, anxiety and social circumstances
SalutogenesisFocuses on resources and processes that support healthCoping, resilience and a sense of coherence
Social Ecological ModelBehaviour is influenced by individual, interpersonal, organizational, community and policy factorsMultilevel tobacco-control intervention
One HealthHuman, animal and environmental health are interconnectedZoonotic disease prevention and environmental health

Biomedical vs biopsychosocial model

BiomedicalBiopsychosocial
Emphasizes biological disease mechanismsIncludes biological, psychological and social influences
Focuses mainly on diagnosis and treatmentAlso considers behaviour, emotions, family and environment
May not explain why patients behave differently with the same diagnosisHelps explain differences in coping, adherence and outcomes